The twentieth-century is fraught with notions of racism and white supremacy, which thus informed and influenced biological sciences of the time[1]. Virginia, in particular, enjoyed her very own Racial Integrity Act, which altered the historical vital records, and barred many people of color in the U.S. from marrying white people [2]. However, wherever there is a rule, there is naturally a loophole. Soldiers began marrying women in countries they were stationed in, sometimes resulting in the women being abandoned and deserted because they were not citizens 

Johns v. Johns is one such case that centers around David William Johns and Chung Jung Kim Johns. David W. Johns was born to a white, middle-class family in Trevorton, Pennsylvania on September 29, 1945 [4]. His father, William J. Johns, worked as a miner for a local, private mining company, and Gloria “Pauline” Reed cared for the home, as well as David W. Johns and his younger sister Sandra B. Johns [5]. Similarly to other young men of his generation, however, David chose to join the U.S. Armed Forces in the early 1960s, while still a minor. David found himself stationed in Korea, where he would meet Chung J. Kim and subsequently married her in Seoul, Korea on July 21, 1964 [6].  

This union, however, did not last long, and David returned alone to the U.S. on August 6, 1964, where he would eventually file a Bill of Annulment a year later on December 23, 1965 [7]. The case shows David W. Johns, the complainant, joined by his mother as his “next friend” filing for divorce, and being counseled by their attorney Denis R. Ayres. The defendant in the Bill of Annulment, Chung, is described as being of the “Yellow Race,” and David being White. Here, Chung is accused of being a prostitute prior to the marriage without the consent or knowledge of David, who had been informed of her alleged occupation. David and Gloria request an annulment in “order that justice be done [8].” 

Because Chung was not living in the U.S., and had to be notified of the situation and case against her. An Order of Publication was sent to her address in Seoul, Korea between January and March of 1966. However, the accusation against Chung has changed: “…Chung Jung Kim Johns, on the grounds of adultery, since the date of marriage, and having been prior to aforesaid marriage, having been a professional prostitute [9].” In this document, she is also being accused of being a prostitute while the marriage took place, an accusation that has not been repeated in the case. Proof that the Order of Publication was produced in May of 1996, with a certificate of publication along with an envelope with Chung’s address in Korea. After the evidence was submitted, the case was referred to a commissioner, A. Carter Whitehead, who oversaw the later deposition. 

The Commissioner’s Report, written by Whitehead, appeals to the court’s empathy, stating that this is indeed a “sad story of a young G.I. serviceman in Korea… sad was his awakening when he realized that he had not only married an oriental, but an oriental prostitute in the bargain [10].” The deposition featured Ayres questioning David W. Johns and his friend, also a member of the U.S. Armed Forces, Raymond S. Atkisson about their relationship with each other, and their relationship to Chung Kim Johns. With the deposition, Ayres establishes that there is no room for reconciliation between David and Chung, and that she had, allegedly, been a prostitute because she had propositioned Raymond [11]. Additionally, it was never asked if she engaged in prostitution during the marriage, as the earlier Order of Publication accused her of. Throughout the twentieth-century, Asian women were often considered promiscuous, often portrayed and understood as either “prostitutes or faceless drudges” [12]. The notion of promiscuity associated with Asian women is prevalent in this time, and it is quite possible that the judge, as well as many of the white people in the case, were influenced and swayed by it. It must have worked, as David was awarded the annulment in June of 1966. 

Do not be mistaken, however, for David was not simply sitting around and waiting for his annulment to finalize. In actuality, according to Vermont birth records, he had been involved with a woman named Claudette Jean Scalabrini and who carried and delivered their child, Joseph D. Johns, on November 30, 1966 [13]. After David separated from Chung, not much is known about her life. On a divorce card, interestingly, it states that her current occupation is “Unknown.” David, on the other hand, would go on to marry Claudette in Massachusetts in 1967 and care for their children.

Works Cited:

  1. Dorr, Gregory Michael, “Principled Expediency: Eugenics, Naim v. Naim, and the Supreme Court,” The American Journal of Legal History (Oxford) 42, no. 2 (1998): 127–128. 
  2. Dorr, Gregory Michael, “Principled Expediency: Eugenics, Naim v. Naim, and the Supreme Court,” 128.
  3. Bureau of Vital Records and Health Statistics, “Commonwealth of Virginia—Report of Divorce or Annulment,” File 66004194, June 17, 1966, accessed Oct. 19, 2026, https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/imageviewer/collections/9280/images/43072_162028006054_0745-00195?queryId=9d1e74b3-e3e2-41e3-b8e1-537f8dfa6d1d&usePUB=true&usePUBJs=true&pId=86196. 
  4. U.S. Census Bureau, “1950 Census of Population and Housing,” Trevorton, Northumberland, Pennsylvania, digital image, sheet no. 35, accessed Oct. 19, 2026, https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/imageviewer/collections/62308/images/43290879-Pennsylvania-065759-0035?usePUB=true&usePUBJs=true&pId=244763796. 
  5. Bureau of Vital Records and Health Statistics, “Commonwealth of Virginia—Report of Divorce or Annulment.” 
  6. John v. John, “Bill of Annulment,” December 23, 1965, Circuit Court of Fairfax, VA.
  7. John v. John, “Bill of Annulment.”
  8. John v. John, “Order of Publication,” January 7, 1966, Circuit Court of Fairfax, VA.
  9. John v. John, “Commissioners Report,” June 8, 1966, page 2, Circuit Court of Fairfax.
  10. John v. John, “Deposition,” June 8, 1966, page 4, Circuit Court of Fairfax.
  11. Lew, Benjamin, “A Less than Perfect Union: Race, Gender, and the Lack of ‘Perfect Plaintiffs’ in Naim v. Naim,” Asian Pacific American Law Journal 28, no. 1 (2024): 34. 
  12. Department of Health, “Copy of Certificate of Birth: State of Vermont,” File 7754, February 10, 1967, accessed October 19, https://www.ancestrylibrary.com/search/collections/1605/records/150566969.