Charles R. Elroy v. Alta G. Elroy1 is a 1966 case of interracial divorce which occurred in the state of Virginia. As this was before the passing of Loving v. Virginia in 1967,2 this case is significant as it acknowledges and confirms an interracial marriage through the granting of a divorce in a state which prohibits marriage between different races.3
The plaintiff Charles R. Elroy—a white man and resident of Alexandria, VA—filed for divorce from Alta G. Elroy (née Ogawa)—a mixed woman of white and Japanese descent—on February 17, 1966 in Staunton, Virginia.4 Charles R. Elroy states that although Alta G. Elroy and himself lived together for six years after being were married on June 27, 1947 in Washington D.C.,5 the couple had been separated for 13 years, concluding their marriage could not be reconciled and should end in a divorce. Neighbor Barbara Ann Owens and Charles’ nephew Vincent C. Scott testified as witnesses, confirming the couple have been separated for a significant amount of time. Ultimately with help of Charles’ attorney Phillip Lee Lotz, the court ruled in favor of Charles, granting him a divorce on March 17, 1966.6 Although the case takes place in Staunton where she resides, Alta notably is not present at the case.
Throughout the court documents, Alta is referred to as “yellow,”7 but this is not always the case on other government documents, signifying her mixed identity could have been used against or for her benefit. For example, on the 1950 US Census, Charles and Alta are both listed as “white.”8 This US Census listing of her race as white could have hid the fact she was in an interracial relationship, causing less backlash from the public. In “A Less than Perfect Union,” Benjamin Lew explores how gender and race affected Asian women in the 20th century, resulting in them being hypersexualized by white Americans.9 In contrast to the census, the repeated classification of Alta as “yellow” in the divorce court records added a racial factor as to why Charles should have perhaps been granted a divorce, suggesting she had perhaps left him because of “promiscuity” that is often associated with Asian women. On her death certificate, Alta is also listed as “white,”10 which indicates the fluidity of how her race was being legally documented persisted even till her death.
After the divorce case, Charles remarried four years later to Margaret Tapley on June 20, 1970 in Alexandria.11 Like Charles, this was also Margaret’s second marriage, and she was listed as “white” on the certificate12. One year later, however, Charles passed away due to “cirrhosis of the liver,” leaving Margaret as a widow with no children.13 Alta lived for longer, seemingly never remarrying, and died in 1994 at the age of 83 due to “respiratory arrest.”14 On her death card, it states she was a widow to “William Elroy,”15 which is likely a miscommunication or error as by the time Charles passed away, they were already divorced. It is also unclear why the card states William as opposed to Charles. In conclusion, it is clear their marriage and subsequent divorce were both certified by Virginia; Charles R. Elroy v. Alta G. Elroy indicates that despite the fact there was Virginia law16 which prohibited interracial marriage, interracial marriage was acknowledged by the state regardless through the granting of a divorce to Charles and Alta—an interracial couple.
- Charles R. Elroy v. Alta G. Elroy, V.A. (25 cir. 1966). ↩︎
- Benjamin Lew, “A Less than Perfect Union,” Asian Pacific American Law Journal 28, no. 1 (2024): 26. ↩︎
- Code of Virginia. § 20-54 (1950). ↩︎
- Charles R. Elroy v. Alta G. Elroy, V.A. (25 cir. 1966). ↩︎
- Charles R. Elroy v. Alta G. Elroy, V.A. (25 cir. 1966). ↩︎
- Charles R. Elroy v. Alta G. Elroy, V.A. (25 cir. 1966). ↩︎
- Charles R. Elroy v. Alta G. Elroy, V.A. (25 cir. 1966). ↩︎
- United States Federal Census, Washington, D.C., ED 1-964A, Seventeenth Census of the United States, 1950, National Archives at Washington, DC. ↩︎
- Benjamin Lew, “A Less than Perfect Union,” Asian Pacific American Law Journal 28, no. 1 (2024): 33-34. ↩︎
- Alta Elroy, “Certificate of Death” (Virginia Department of Health, Richmond, VA, USA, 1994). ↩︎
- “Marriage Record” (Virginia Department of Health, Richmond, VA, USA, 1970). ↩︎
- “Marriage Record” (Virginia Department of Health, Richmond, VA, USA, 1970). ↩︎
- Charles Elroy, “Certificate of Death (Virginia Department of Health, Richmond, VA, USA, 1971). ↩︎
- Alta Elroy, “Certificate of Death” (Virginia Department of Health, Richmond, VA, USA, 1994). ↩︎
- Alta Elroy, “Certificate of Death” (Virginia Department of Health, Richmond, VA, USA, 1994). ↩︎
- Code of Virginia. § 20-54 (1950). ↩︎