The case Robert L. Davis vs. Fumiko Oomura Davis began on May 31st 1960 in Charlottesville, Virginia. The plaintiff in this case was Robert Lewis Davis. Born in 1936, Robert was a member of the air force for 21 years.(1) He was deployed in Japan where he met the defendant Fumiko Oomura Davis. Fumiko was a Japanese woman living in Kyushu-Fukuoka city. She and Robert had a child together and were married on June 17th, 1958.(2)
Sometime between late 1958 and early 1959, Robert returned to the U.S. without Fumiko. In the summer of 1960, he filed for an annulment at Charlottesville Courthouse under the 1950 code of Virginia. The court sent out a summons for Fumiko to appear both by mail and by newspaper in the Daily Progress.(3) Fumiko never appeared in front of the court, since she was in Japan. The court interviewed Robert, his mother, and his friend from the military who all corroborated Robert’s story that Fumiko was Japanese and that under Virginia law the marriage was invalid. The court eventually agreed to grant Robert the annulment, saying that since Fumiko never appeared to testify they had to move forward.(4)

(5)
Six months after getting the annulment, Robert married Nancy Jean Martin in Charlottesville on January 18th 1961.(6)


(7)
But that wasn’t the first time Robert married Nancy. On August 9th, 1959, he and Nancy were married in Washington, D.C., almost a year before he filed for annulment and a year after his marriage to Fumiko.(8) Robert was a bigamist, a fact that was never brought up during the case. He likely filed for an annulment when he and Nancy moved back to his hometown of Charlottesville in order to validate his marriage to Nancy and then married her again in Virginia to avoid being found out.
As discussed in A Less than Perfect Union, many men in the military did bring back wives they married overseas to the U.S. to become citizens. It became a problem for the military because of the immigrant quota and led to the passing of the War Brides Act, which allowed military spouses to immigrate despite the quota.(9) However, Robert didn’t attempt to bring Fumiko with him to the U.S. and instead left Fumiko and their child in Japan.
Robert ‘Bob’ Davis has no other records of his first marriage. His friends and family knew him as Bob, a loving husband.(10) Reconstructed family trees don’t include another child. In part, this is because there are no records of Fumiko or their child, at least not ones accessible in the U.S. Robert appears to be able to successfully erase his first marriage and move on in his marriage to Nancy.
Notes:
“Robert Lewis “Bob” Davis (1936-2016) – Find a Grave Memorial,” Find A Grave. October 2016, https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/170828813/robert_lewis-davis#.
Decree for Annulment for Robert L. Davis and Fumiko Oomura Davis, September 16, 1960, File Number 4682, Charlottesville
Robert L. Davis v. Fumiko Oomura Davis, COB 25 (Va. 1960)
Robert L. Davis v. Fumiko Oomura Davis, COB 25 (Va. 1960)
Decree for Annulment for Robert L. Davis and Fumiko Oomura Davis, September 16, 1960, File Number 4682, Charlottesville
Marriage of Certificate for Robert Lewis Davis and Nancy Jean Martin, January 18, 1961, File Number 96, Charlottesville
Nancy Jean Martin Davis. Photograph. Bullock Funeral Home. November 11, 2021, https://www.bullockfuneralhome.com/obituary/Nancy-Davis
Superior Court of the District of Columbia. 1959. “Marriage Bureau.” MARR008. Superior Court of the District of Columbia.
Benjamin Lew, “A Less Than Perfect Union,” Asian Pacific American Law Journal 28, no. 1 (Spring 2024): 25-50
The Item Archive: Tuesday, October 4, 2016 • Sumter, South Carolina Page 15